Conservative women active in politics are on the rise across the country. Sadly, they still have a hard time getting respect, equal treatment, are not elected nearly as often as men and are frequently relegated to behind-the-scenes background roles. (I do have to point out that the Dems here do a much better job at electing women – abt 50% of the Democrats in the Utah House are women – just about the right proportion, don’t you think?)
Women who are politically powerful are often called, well, bitchy and are mocked for their conservative views. Why is that? Maybe those women should just claim it as a title of honor and go ahead and get the T-shirt as a card-carrying member of the “club”……
Seriously – do men hear these kind of things? (Actual quotes, by the way)
“Sure I’ll support you – but I sure don’t get why your husband LETS you do this”
*”You can’t possibly be conservative. Your wife works“
*”Please don’t talk to people. They are intimidated by strong women and it hurts my campaign.”
*”If you run, they’ll just crucify you because you still have kids at home.”
*”Get a job and stop being a sponge on society” (to a homemaker volunteering in the political arena)
*”Shouldn’t you be home more?”
*”You don’t deserve to get reimbursed for mileage but I’ll allow you to fill the gas tank” (said to a MAYOR by a full-time employee with a city vehicle and an expense account)
*”We are going to have trouble with drama from the women on the city council” (said by a sitting mayor to a city council with ONE woman on it)
*”Leave politics to the men – women aren’t cut out for it.“
*”There’s a good-ole boy system around here and we have our way of doing things” – S. Utah old-timer
So what’s the solution? Give up? Go away? Stay home? Be quiet? No! I would even say HE(CK) NO! We need MORE women involved in politics. We need MORE women willing to speak up and let their voices be heard. We need MORE women willing to move to the front of the line, not just accept a background role with the crumbs that fall from the table. We need MORE women involved as political pundits, policy experts, elected officials, social media experts, and as LEADERS across the political spectrum. We need more men who are not intimidated by strong women. We need more men who are good and truly respectful and supportive. We need more men who consider women in politics their peers, not their inferiors. In short, we need men AND women of courage and moral conviction to be actively engaged in this cause.
It’s time for women to come into their own on the political scene. We have some great examples of conservative women making a real difference in Utah politics like Jennifer Scott, original campaign manager and now district director for Congressman Jason Chaffetz, Deidre Henderson, current campaign manager for Chaffetz, Representative Becky Lockhart from Provo, Senator Margaret Dayton from Orem, Becky Pirente, leader in the 9-12 movement, Jane Hawley, community activist and leader in southern Utah, Joni Crane doing the same in the Uintah basin, Mia Love and Melissa Johnson, mayors of Saratoga Springs and West Jordan, respectively, Cherilyn Eagar, brave enough to be running for US Senate and a number of others. They are awesome. And, we need MORE. Step up. Be counted. Be determined. Don’t be afraid to rock the boat. And get a tough skin – you’ll need it (but it’s worth it).
April 15, 2010 at 7:24 am
Don’t leave us hangin’, Holly. Should misogynists be protected from themselves? They’re big boys, right? If they said those things, they should live with the consequences. Protecting them only gives them opportunity for more misogyny, no? Additionally, a post like this is a lot more interesting, gets a lot more attention, and likely has more impact if you name names.
April 15, 2010 at 7:29 am
Please name a conservative woman who is newly running for the legislature this year.
Having trouble? The “glass ceiling” you speak of is oddly devoid of anyone challenging it. Which begs the question: If a glass ceiling exists with no one attempting to crack it, does it really exist?
April 15, 2010 at 7:43 am
Arbitrary litmus test, Run. Eagar is running for the U.S. Senate and many women in recent years have tried–some succeeded–to seek public office in Utah. You seem to be arguing that every single election a woman must run specifically for the Legislature otherwise it’s safe to speculate that a glass ceiling doesn’t exist? That’s silly.
April 15, 2010 at 7:58 am
And let’s now forget founder of The STAR Forum, Jacqueline Smith. (Just had to plug myself, there.)
April 15, 2010 at 7:59 am
Okay I meant let’s NOT forget, Jacqueline Smith. typo
April 15, 2010 at 9:42 am
[...] Utah's Glass Ceiling « Holly On The Hill [...]
April 15, 2010 at 9:43 am
[...] Utah's Glass Ceiling « Holly On The Hill [...]
April 15, 2010 at 11:05 am
I love this post! I have no plans currently to run for political office but I’ve always worked in male-dominated fields and have worked behind the scenes for other Candidates. I actually enjoy working with men- you just have to know how they think and work around it.
I also like how you point out that we need MEN who are comfortable with women being their equals. One of my favorite political wives is Laura Bridgewater- a brilliant, articulate woman with a phd and part-time BYU Prof. So not the typical ‘Barbie Doll’ political wife. It says a lot about her spouse too that he’s perfectly happy and proud to have a wife who’s more than pretty wallpaper.
We do need more women AND men who value the viewpoints and roles of women in politics.
April 15, 2010 at 12:24 pm
And……we have HOLLY ON THE HILL — thanks for your inspiration!
April 15, 2010 at 4:47 pm
For once I agree completely with you Holly. There should be more involvement of women in state politics. I am glad that you noticed that we Democrats have a better track record of balance and equality where gender is concerned.
Unfortunately you described the problem in Utah without having the courage to be honest about the underlying cause which is the tradition and attitude of the LDS church with its all male hierarchy of leaders. One does not need to look too hard at the Utah Legislature to see the striking similarities with the LDS church in membership and attitudes toward women in leadership roles.
You can crusade all you like but until one changes the other is going to remain pretty much the same in the theocracy we call Utah.
April 15, 2010 at 8:01 pm
Your stalker JBT can’t agree with you without finding a way to slam you. “without having the courage to be honest…”
April 15, 2010 at 8:07 pm
JBT:
The problem isn’t with the male Priesthood of the LDS church. The leadership has been completely neutral on appropriate gender roles in politics.
As a Utah transplant, I have been shocked at some of the sexist comments made mostly by members of the LDS church towards Senate candidate Eagar. There exists a minority prejudiced because Eagar is a woman, a divorcee, isn’t spending time with her (grown!) kids, or other reasons.
Finally, I believe Holly with her vast Utah political acumen would make a Governor or wherever her political ambitions take her.
April 15, 2010 at 8:12 pm
JBT is correct. The LDS culture is one where many women feel it is a HIGHER calling to be home with their children. But going beyond that I think is trying to slam the culture and the church in his post.
April 16, 2010 at 8:41 am
Nacilbupera is missing the point entirely. The culture of the state of Utah is largely the culture of LDS church which is strongly influenced by the design of its ecclesiastical “government” which consists of an all male hierarchy. Women are denied leadership positions that are equal to men. This is neither slamming the LDS culture or THE church, it is simply a statement of fact. Whether or not the “church” leadership has issued a statement concerning women in politics is irrelevant.
To the anonymous John who accuses me of not having the “courage to be honest”, in all modesty I believe it IS my willingness to be completely honest that gets all of your conservative’s panties in a bunch. You folks just don’t want to hear anything that differs from what you hear in your narrow homogeneous circle of conservative, LDS, Republican friends and neighbors.
August 21, 2010 at 7:42 am
Thanks to you for this awesome article. I’ve read id for a few months now and they’re always very informative. Thanks!